SteveX
Senior Member
- Joined
- Oct 27, 2009
- Messages
- 1,512
- Reaction score
- 18
Hi Gents,
Not sure if you saw my post in suspension around taking the front of my car apart about 10 times and replacing everything to cure a clonk over bumps, but I eventually found out it's the roof!!!
It's a W209, and there is a distinct clonk and rattle when the car is twisting, so left wheel down or up vs the right wheel, going over a bump with the wheels at the same time, IE sleeping policeman is fine.
It's definitely coming from where the roof attaches to the front, the sound kind of comes through the pillars and near the dash, hence I thought it was the top mounts and suspension I had recently changed.
I've had the roof part way down, and shaken the roof, the frame is solid, and there appears to be just two rather solid catches at the front near the top of the screen. I can't see any obvious way's to adjust it, and it opens and closes perfectly. When it's up it's locked on solid, can't move it or shake it and lines up perfect, when it's in the boot, again all locked away nice and solid.
The obvious difference, when it's down, no noise (apart from a very minor creak from the hood compartment which you can barely hear). When it's up, clonk and rattle over uneven road surfaces.
The rubbers and hinges / joints were all cleaned by me and lubed with silicon earlier this year and was perfect.
No clue what is causing the noise or how to resolve at the moment.
Any ideas appreciated.
Thanks,
Steve
Not sure if you saw my post in suspension around taking the front of my car apart about 10 times and replacing everything to cure a clonk over bumps, but I eventually found out it's the roof!!!
It's a W209, and there is a distinct clonk and rattle when the car is twisting, so left wheel down or up vs the right wheel, going over a bump with the wheels at the same time, IE sleeping policeman is fine.
It's definitely coming from where the roof attaches to the front, the sound kind of comes through the pillars and near the dash, hence I thought it was the top mounts and suspension I had recently changed.
I've had the roof part way down, and shaken the roof, the frame is solid, and there appears to be just two rather solid catches at the front near the top of the screen. I can't see any obvious way's to adjust it, and it opens and closes perfectly. When it's up it's locked on solid, can't move it or shake it and lines up perfect, when it's in the boot, again all locked away nice and solid.
The obvious difference, when it's down, no noise (apart from a very minor creak from the hood compartment which you can barely hear). When it's up, clonk and rattle over uneven road surfaces.
The rubbers and hinges / joints were all cleaned by me and lubed with silicon earlier this year and was perfect.
No clue what is causing the noise or how to resolve at the moment.
Any ideas appreciated.
Thanks,
Steve