Looking back what is the best car and worst car you’ve owned and why

malcolm E53 AMG

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2005
Messages
8,737
Reaction score
7,043
The demographic of this forum is mainly mid-life to retired so in general we’ve all owned a few cars so which one really sticks in the memory - good and bad!

My fondest memory is the 2000 reg S210 320cdi Avantgarde I recall Jeremy Clarkson when he road tested the car commented ‘it’s every car you’ll ever need’ and I totally agree with that it sums the car up perfectly. It had the best diesel engine I’ve had the pleasure to own the OM613 which was smooth, powerful and economical and importantly reliable. The car handled well for a large estate mainly due to the excellent aerodynamics and hardly suffered any buffeting at high speed on motorways in fact the car almost drove itself in that respect. For such a big car it handled well in the twisty bits very sure footed on its 215 section tyres. We all know the body rotted so there was usually some remedial work to be done to keep that at bay but that was down to the poor quality steel MB were using at the time. When I sold the car at 90k miles the engine and transmission still performed perfectly and had MB still been manufacturing the vehicle (with better steel) I would have bought another.

The candidate for worst car (there are a few) sadly goes to a 1975 Dolomite Sprint made at the height of the BL fiasco. It was fundamentally a good car with a revolutionary 16 valve cylinder head but the overall engineering and quality of manufacturing let the car down, everything rotted in those days so that was a given. It was the only car that left me stranded 100 miles from home and had to be recovered by the AA. The problem was the external clutch actuation flat bar which was welded to a round actuating shaft that entered the bell housing, instead of machining the end of the flat bar with an oblong hole they used a round hole to sit a round shaft in and relied on the weld to hold it which it did - for a while. I dread to think how many cars had to be recovered because of this basic manufacturing fault.

I could go on but I won’t that’s basically the best and worst cars I’ve owned. I won’t comment on the E53 S213 I own currently it’s too early to say how it compares overall to the S210 but it might get there.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0126.jpeg
    IMG_0126.jpeg
    150.4 KB · Views: 9

sl500amgsport

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 25, 2017
Messages
2,560
Reaction score
2,919
Location
Essex
Your Mercedes
E53AMG
Best car by far was the SL500, didn't miss a beat or let me down in 5 years ownership, worst was a 1981 Ford Escort 1.6 Ghia, broke down everything I drove through a large puddle!

Some pics from the history books!
3a560ea70a6fe7affbe253c64b61c43a.jpg
4c4a8f48983d47a4e82434d465f5c52c.jpg
48596349b24eeff543a5e7a308354744.jpg
0cd691c64e12877c67108a80818e3d97.jpg
74ef73baccecf92c6091906185c9cd56.jpg
2183f5299e91501d18beae6fe869c2bb.jpg


Sent from my SM-G988B using Tapatalk
 

Blobcat

Moderator
Joined
Feb 8, 2006
Messages
42,592
Reaction score
34,121
Location
Grange Moor
Your Mercedes
R171 SLK280, Smart R451, 997 C2S, VW ID.5, R1250 GSA TE 40th, CBR600FP
The demographic of this forum is mainly mid-life to retired so in general we’ve all owned a few cars so which one really sticks in the memory - good and bad!

My fondest memory is the 2000 reg S210 320cdi Avantgarde I recall Jeremy Clarkson when he road tested the car commented ‘it’s every car you’ll ever need’ and I totally agree with that it sums the car up perfectly. It had the best diesel engine I’ve had the pleasure to own the OM613 which was smooth, powerful and economical and importantly reliable. The car handled well for a large estate mainly due to the excellent aerodynamics and hardly suffered any buffeting at high speed on motorways in fact the car almost drove itself in that respect. For such a big car it handled well in the twisty bits very sure footed on its 215 section tyres. We all know the body rotted so there was usually some remedial work to be done to keep that at bay but that was down to the poor quality steel MB were using at the time. When I sold the car at 90k miles the engine and transmission still performed perfectly and had MB still been manufacturing the vehicle (with better steel) I would have bought another.

The candidate for worst car (there are a few) sadly goes to a 1975 Dolomite Sprint made at the height of the BL fiasco. It was fundamentally a good car with a revolutionary 16 valve cylinder head but the overall engineering and quality of manufacturing let the car down, everything rotted in those days so that was a given. It was the only car that left me stranded 100 miles from home and had to be recovered by the AA. The problem was the external clutch actuation flat bar which was welded to a round actuating shaft that entered the bell housing, instead of machining the end of the flat bar with an oblong hole they used a round hole to sit a round shaft in and relied on the weld to hold it which it did - for a while. I dread to think how many cars had to be recovered because of this basic manufacturing fault.

I could go on but I won’t that’s basically the best and worst cars I’ve owned. I won’t comment on the E53 S213 I own currently it’s too early to say how it compares overall to the S210 but it might get there.
I think my “Best Car” was my first Mercedes - W210 E320 CDI in Violane with Orion Grey leather interior - drove it to from 22,000 to 136,000 miles - the engine was better when I sold it than when I first bought it. Loved that car. My 911 is also up there on my best cars, as is my SLK.
Worst is probably a 1.6 Ford Sierra that the sunroof leaked onto my lap. Although the FIAT Marea Weekends I had as longish term hire cars for work were absolutely dire… one the gearbox fell out of… the other was built as a left hand drive so the fog light would come on when you selected reverse and the reversing light when you put the fog light on… also you couldn’t adjust the passenger side mirror enough to see back with it as it was a drivers mirror with less adjustment… Tony really should have Fixed It Again…
 

mioba

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2006
Messages
9,394
Reaction score
6,011
Location
Nottingham
Your Mercedes
W124/E200, W220/S320CDI, W205/C200, W251/R350CDI 4Matic
1st Beat my old W124. Total engineering from every screw upwards and the best drive of all.

2nd Best is my W220 with the Om648. Been absolute trouble free. Engine been absolute gem.

Worst is the W251 with the OM642. Turbo actuator, oil cooler seals, orange batwing seals. Has too many weak points.

My decision is based on the engines.

Put the OM648 in the W251. That would be majestic.
 

rifiki

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2015
Messages
968
Reaction score
667
Location
Worksop
Your Mercedes
CLK W209 W121190B
MB 190B, Peugeot 403 in East and Central Africa.
Toyota Land Cruiser in Saudi Arabia.
All had one thing in common, shear brute strength, particularly The Land Cruiser.
The Marina Coupe I had in UK would not have lasted 5 minutes on corrugated dirt roads.
 

LostKiwi

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2006
Messages
32,038
Reaction score
22,894
Location
Midlands / Charente-Maritime
Your Mercedes
'93 500SL-32, '01 W210 Estate E240 (RIP), 02 R230 SL500, 04 Smart Roadster Coupe, 11 R350CDi
I have no single best as each of the following was best in its own way but not so good in others.

Best for fun: Smart Roadster. Bought in 2013 and still have it. More smiles per gallon than anything else I've owned. Surprisingly reliable too

Best for summer touring: R129 (R230 very close second).

Best load lugger: R350 CDi. Nothing else comes close.

Best sounding: Land rover FC101 with custom exhaust. It won a prize at a land rover meet for best sounding vehicle. It sounded awesome.

Best for getting A to B quickly: 2000 Audi S3. Astonishingly quick in it's day. (R230 very close second if it's dry).

Best reliability: 1999 Volvo T5 SE. 220k miles with only one engine mount and a throttle body outside normal services. Oh...and lots of front tyres.... (and it was superbly comfortable, quick and sounded amazing). Probably best all rounder.

Best at taking up my time: 2005 Saab 9-3. That thing spent more time with the bonnet up than bonnet down. Pity as when it worked it was superb.
 
Last edited:

ALFAitalia

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2025
Messages
1,066
Reaction score
1,391
Location
Pagham, Bognor Regis
Your Mercedes
2010 Mercedes W212 E350 CDI Sport
Well "Best" is a difficult one.....Best comfort is probably my current 212.....but best handing is probably my old modified Mitsi GTO TT. Most reliable....surprise, surprise......was my ALDFA 159 2.0 JTDM....175,000 miles and never let me down with not a lot more than servicing and consumable parts.

Worst is more difficult as I don't tend to buy bad cars!! If you would have asked me a few months into 212 ownership I would have said that!!....needed a new turbo, new radiator, new front springs etc etc etc. But she's all fettled now and seems fine. My CLK200K 209 was not great....reliable....but too slow and boring to drive.....would be much better with the 320 I'm sure....but the 200 did not have enough power to break traction unless it was wet (AMG pack and big staggered tyres did not help!).....pretty though in blue with grey skin.
Worst built.....well I'm sure its not typical of the breed.....but I had an E30 318i. the engine was great.....but the rust, squeaks, rattles, wind noise, poor quality cloth seats that wore through in under 80k miles. It was just a very poor example.
 
OP
malcolm E53 AMG

malcolm E53 AMG

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2005
Messages
8,737
Reaction score
7,043
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread starter
  • #8
MB 190B, Peugeot 403 in East and Central Africa.
Toyota Land Cruiser in Saudi Arabia.
All had one thing in common, shear brute strength, particularly The Land Cruiser.
The Marina Coupe I had in UK would not have lasted 5 minutes on corrugated dirt roads.
I like the Aussie comment on using a Range Rover in the outback ‘you can travel into the outback with a Range Rover but if you want to come back use a Land Cruiser’ always makes me smile.
 

LostKiwi

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2006
Messages
32,038
Reaction score
22,894
Location
Midlands / Charente-Maritime
Your Mercedes
'93 500SL-32, '01 W210 Estate E240 (RIP), 02 R230 SL500, 04 Smart Roadster Coupe, 11 R350CDi
I like the Aussie comment on using a Range Rover in the outback ‘you can travel into the outback with a Range Rover but if you want to come back use a Land Cruiser’ always makes me smile.
Ironically my Range Rover Classic 3.9 V8 gave me much less trouble than my Land cruiser 3.4V6!
 
OP
malcolm E53 AMG

malcolm E53 AMG

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2005
Messages
8,737
Reaction score
7,043
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread starter
  • #10
Ironically my Range Rover Classic 3.9 V8 gave me much less trouble than my Land cruiser 3.4V6!
I still have a 3.5 Rover SD1 that engine is 100% reliable so it doesn’t surprise me assuming the 3.9 V8 Range Rover was based on the old Buick design
 

markben

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2017
Messages
331
Reaction score
435
Location
Bristol UK
Your Mercedes
w220 2004 S320L CDI
Worst cars: :eek:

1. 1978 'top end' brand new British Leyland Austin Allegro HL 1750 c.c. company car in then fashionable Chocolate Brown with velour seats (wow!). Lively performance & comfortable with Hydrolastic suspension, would do 110 mph down hill on the M5 motorway with a following wind. But spent more time off the road than on it with various mechanical issues. Nicknamed 'The All Aggro' as a result.

2. Similar vintage 'Wedge shape' BL Austin Princess. Woefully inadequate performance from the antiquated 1800 cc engine + suffered from terminal understeer. Best forgotten.

Best cars: :)

1. Mid 1980's Citroen CX 2400 GTI's (x2). Fabulous & reliable hydro pneumatic ride comfort, pin-sharp steering & braking, great performance. I miss those incredibly advanced French cars for their time and would still own & drive one if I could.

2. 1996 'N' registered Mercedes W124 E280 facelift petrol estate (wagon). 'Only' 4 speed auto with 'adequate' performance, but the engine was quiet & as smooth as silk and the ride comfort was superb even on coil springs. Probably my favourite?

3. 2 x circa 2000 / 2001 facelift Mercedes W210 V8 E55 a.m.g. estates (wagons). Fabulous combination of seamless power, practicality & ride comfort + surprisingly economical if driven gently (often 30+ mpg - can you believe that?!). The only problem: the latter one suffered from terminal 'Filofilm' structural corrosion due to the infamous Mercedes manufacturing cost-cutting measures in those times, and was later scrapped. RIP my E55 & those of that era which have, sadly, been consigned to the Breaker's yard.

4. Not forgetting.. my current & treasured / immaculate late 2004 facelift Mercedes W220 S320L OM648 cdi engine aka 'The Limo'. Owned for 9 years & 50k miles, terrific lazy torque & power, 30+mpg around town, up to 47 mpg on a run. Now at 150k miles & still going strong. A few niggles with the Airmatic / ADS + a couple of un-anticipated (but not serious / unduly costly) mechanical repairs - for which I forgive it. All considered, the Best car I've ever owned. And.. at nearly 21 years old (!), IMHO it still looks 'Timelessly Elegant' / wins the supermarket car park Beauty Contest (compared with many modern & ubiquitous SUVs?) & is regularly admired by passers-by.20220410_105626.jpg :).

Happy days & memories, for better or worse? ;)
 
Last edited:

fabes

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 14, 2015
Messages
1,137
Reaction score
1,110
Location
Southampton
Your Mercedes
AMG SLK55 & CLA SB
Laguna 2.2dci Initiale estate (02 reg, bought 1 year old)
In deep red with a svelte grey leather interior
All the toys, plenty of go and a nice drive.

When it wasn't broken

And it was frequently broken, costing Renault and then the aftermarket warranty I bought a large fortune.
Cylinders, Aircon, injectors, parking sensors, fuelling issues

Worst car (for reliability) but a ruddy good car otherwise.

Best car...

I love the AMG SLK55 I have
The only car I ever regretted trading in as I was doing so was my (odd) C class coupe c220cdi with a sequentronic gearbox (yes ,I was 'that' person) but it was for my Saab 9-3 2.0T Aero convertible which I then had remapped.

The Saab is the only car, 8 years later, I have ever considered buying back and, in owning it for 5 years, the longest I have ever owned a car.

Might not be the best car, but in my heart, my favourite / the one I gelled with the most.
God it was good in gear from 20...
 

Srdl

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2015
Messages
8,043
Reaction score
7,421
Location
New Forest, Hampshire
Your Mercedes
GLC43 AMG 2018 (X253)
My best is definitely my current GLC 43.

The worst probably ought to be one of the two 1.3 Morris Marinas I had in my younger days but I didn’t know any better then. Or my Cavalier SRi, which went well in a straight line but absolutely detested corners.

1763919539898.jpeg

The MG Maestro was fun
1763919596373.jpeg
 

fabes

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 14, 2015
Messages
1,137
Reaction score
1,110
Location
Southampton
Your Mercedes
AMG SLK55 & CLA SB
I had a B reg black MG Maestro (with added 'mayo')
I'll bet yours was the fancy EFI 2 litre ?
Did it have the talking dash aswell?
 

bladecrazy

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2020
Messages
636
Reaction score
650
Location
bolton
Your Mercedes
tesla model 3 performance /honda cd175/w123 300d gertrude.
worst was a 1970 mini 850, as a 17 year old on a terrible wage it was all i could insure, no working heater and wet carpets made winter so miserable , favorite car after that was a metalic gold 2 door mk1 escort 1100L with tiger print seat covers .
 

sonic

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2009
Messages
4,153
Reaction score
3,132
Location
Staffordshire
Your Mercedes
E350CDI, SLC250d, FJR 1300
Best cars Audi GT Coupe, & a VW Golf 16V, both bulletproof reliable. The wife had a Peugeot 205 GTI 1600, nice but I preferred the Golf.
MB CLK 270 CDI, very reliable sold with 120K miles on the clock. Still very happy with my E350CDI, bought 6 months old, now 14 years old.
I joined the police service early 80's, eventually got the drive some very nice cars. Favourits Vauxhall Senator 24V, & Volvo T5's ours were chipped by Volvo. We also had a VW Jetta with a 2.7 V6 on demo from VW, that was really quick.
 
OP
malcolm E53 AMG

malcolm E53 AMG

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2005
Messages
8,737
Reaction score
7,043
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread starter
  • #17
worst was a 1970 mini 850, as a 17 year old on a terrible wage it was all i could insure, no working heater and wet carpets made winter so miserable , favorite car after that was a metalic gold 2 door mk1 escort 1100L with tiger print seat covers .
I had the same vintage Mini 1000 (in aqua) every time it rained the distributor just behind the front grill got wet and the car started misfiring. I remember there was an aftermarket rubber boot you could fit to the distributor with varying success so my father fashioned a home made grill shutter which almost solved the problem. In those days I was commuting every week from Howden to Leicester on the M1 and hoped it was a dry journey. The car never actually let me down but had a few issues.
 

SL63 Mark

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 1, 2012
Messages
5,110
Reaction score
3,277
Location
Wilts
Your Mercedes
2016 SL63 AMG
I would like to add my 1971, 1.3 Morris Marina Coupe, in Harvest Gold to the list of BL cars above. Does the Marina have more mentions in this list than any other car ? Truly horrible, it smelt bad. Unreliable. Rusty. Underpowered. Terminal head gasket/engine problems, slow, vague steering, no handling to speak of.

"Best" car is tricky. I think that has to be the R231 SL63, still no trouble in three years of ownership, and still gives me a thrill every time I take it out.

I did love my 1975 2.7 Porsche 911 targa though, what a car, even with all its problems. For some reason I remember that with more fondness than any of my other 911s.

The Renault 5 Turbos were fun, too. Especially the original Gordini Turbo I owned back in the late 80s. A real rocket powered roller skate.
 
Last edited:

Blobcat

Moderator
Joined
Feb 8, 2006
Messages
42,592
Reaction score
34,121
Location
Grange Moor
Your Mercedes
R171 SLK280, Smart R451, 997 C2S, VW ID.5, R1250 GSA TE 40th, CBR600FP
I would like to add my 1971, 1.3 Morris Marina Coupe, in Harvest Gold to the list of BL cars above. Does the Marina have more mentions in this list than any other car ? Truly horrible, it smelt bad. Unreliable. Rusty. Underpowered. Terminal head gasket/engine problems, slow, vague steering, no handling to speak of.

"Best" car is tricky. I think that has to be the R231 SL63, still no trouble in three years of ownership, and still gives me a thrill every time I take it out.

I did love my 1975 2.7 Porsche 911 targa though, what a car, even with all its problems. For some reason I remember that with more fondness than any of my other 911s.

The Renault 5 Turbos were fun, too. Especially the original Gordini Turbo I owned back in the late 80s. A real rocket powered roller skate.
My father’s Morris Marina estate is still going… found someone on YouTube bought it recently.


That was a truly awful car, changed it for a Triumph 2.5pi estate whilst we were on holiday in Bournemouth. Pulled into a fuel station for petrol, came out with a Triumph. :)
 

SL63 Mark

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 1, 2012
Messages
5,110
Reaction score
3,277
Location
Wilts
Your Mercedes
2016 SL63 AMG
My father’s Morris Marina estate is still going… found someone on YouTube bought it recently.


That was a truly awful car, changed it for a Triumph 2.5pi estate whilst we were on holiday in Bournemouth. Pulled into a fuel station for petrol, came out with a Triumph. :)
That's the same colour. It is giving me flashbacks, I think I may have PTSD.o_O
 


Chris Knott Insurance, see oursticky posts here!
www.ckinsurance.co.uk
Top Bottom