Xenons...

Rappey69

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2008
Messages
1,893
Reaction score
388
Location
hants
Your Mercedes
c220 w204 amg sport
My beam cut off is very sharp.
Am sure it is... When you look into the headlight alignment thingy at a test station you will have a well defined cut off point,even with a xenon fitted to a halogen reflector - but -
With a halogen bulb above the cut off line will be black (no light scatter)
With a xenon bulb it will be very slightly illuminated (this is the scatter)
Its all down to the tester and how much knowledge of xenon v halogen in non standard fitments !

A halogen bulb has a filament that runs left to right in its reflector so we have a given point or origin for the light.
A xenon runs equivalent of front to rear, so its point of origin will cross where the halogen one does, but it will also continue past that point, and this is where the light scatter will come from.

so what happens with motorcycles as many of them are fitting xenons in place of halogens ??
 

Christian

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 4, 2011
Messages
710
Reaction score
34
Location
Horsham
Your Mercedes
w205 AMG Edition, Panasonic washing machine :)
:D Any 500w H7 bulbs on the market?
 

BillyBoy

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2003
Messages
1,177
Reaction score
426
Your Mercedes
W213 E400d All Terrain
I know you must have the self leveling Malc...it's just I feel that it's overkill with the self leveling suspension.(To avoid confusion...I have Xenons).

I suspect the reason for both being fitted may be response time. Depending on the type of self levelling suspension fitted, some can take many seconds if not minutes to reach the correct attitude as they are designed to cope with different loads, but not dynamically changing loads. The motor actuators in the lights, however, are able to provide real time adjustment based on feedback from the cars sensors.

Cheers,
Bill
 
OP
87henderson

87henderson

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2011
Messages
123
Reaction score
0
Location
Glasgow, Scotland
Your Mercedes
Mercedes C180 Kompressor
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread starter
  • #64
Naraic.. My attitude towards the policeman is none of your concern! He treated me like a thug... Threatened to "go through" my car and spoke to me like a piece of ****! All because of my lights.. What would have been wrong with him advising me and treating me like a road user with tax, a valid mot, up to date insurance and a clean licence.. All of which i have! If u read my original post in which i said i do not dispute the law u cod have used ur "brain" and realised in no way was i cheeky or rude to the policeman!
 

Naraic

Moderator
Joined
Mar 4, 2010
Messages
10,686
Reaction score
1,274
Your Mercedes
2005 CL500.
Naraic.. My attitude towards the policeman is none of your concern! He treated me like a thug... Threatened to "go through" my car and spoke to me like a piece of ****! All because of my lights.. What would have been wrong with him advising me and treating me like a road user with tax, a valid mot, up to date insurance and a clean licence.. All of which i have! If u read my original post in which i said i do not dispute the law u cod have used ur "brain" and realised in no way was i cheeky or rude to the policeman!

See post 11...you are a plonker.
 

MisterGee

New Member
Joined
Apr 2, 2012
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
Location
London
Your Mercedes
W203
Know your Legislation -

Lifted from another forum I belong to:-:)

Read into it what you will
______________________________________________________________


Know Your Legislation

I am creating this post not for scaremongering, but to educate on current and proposed legislation with regards to modified vehicles. Most of this legislation has been in place for years, but many people either have never heard of it or have no understanding of it. Recently the organisations involved in policing these regulations have begun to enforce them more thoroughly.

Forthcoming MOT regulations
First the good news. After consultation with a number of agencies and organisations the proposed changes to the MOT system to be implemented in January 2012 have been amended. Therefore:

• There will NOT be a total ban on the use/sale of aftermarket HID kits, which was a major part of the proposal. The current MOT rules state

High Intensity Discharge (HID) and LED dipped beam headlamps (whether original fitment or after-market) must be fitted with a headlamp washing system (a wiper is not required) and be self levelling. This may be achieved by the use of either headlamp or suspension levelling systems. However, some high performance vehicles fitted with HID headlamps that have limited luggage space and stiff suspension do not require a self-levelling system.

Reason for failure: A mandatory headlamp levelling or cleaning device missing, inoperative or otherwise obviously defective

• There will not be a ban on “illegal” engine tuning. Frankly there was no way a visual inspection could identify an aftermarket chip or re-map anyway, and this proposal was met with universal contempt by MOT testers. The only reference in the new manual to this is that modified cars must meet the correct emissions level for the year of engine.

Changes to the MOT that could affect lowered cars

These are the changes that have been implemented.

• Check that there is enough clearance of the axle or suspension with the bump stop or chassis
• Check that there is sufficient clearance from body to wheels

Reason for failure:
Inadequate Clearance of the axle or suspension with the bump stop or chassis.

Inadequate clearance between body and wheels.

Deliberate modification which significantly reduces the original strength, excessive corrosion, severe distortion, a fracture or an inadequate repair of a load bearing member or its supporting structure or supporting panelling within 30cm of any sub-frame, spring or a suspension component mounting, that is, within a ‘prescribed area

The key word in the first definitions is ‘inadequate’. This leaves it to the discretion of the MOT tester on what classes as inadequate. It’s not a massive problem, as I’d imagine most lowered car owners will have a friendly MOT tester that they use anyway. If not it might be time to find one. The 2nd part is interesting, for instance a chassis C notch could be seen as reducing the strength of the supporting structure for the front subframe.

That’s about all we can find that affects modified cars in the new manual, so much better than first thought.

Vehicle Registration Laws

There are 2 different organisations involved in this process.

The DVLA maintain the database that contains all the drivers and all the vehicles in the UK.

VOSA regulate the MOT test and perform roadside checks to improve road safety.

The “8 points” Registration System

To put this system into context, people must understand that you never own the registration document for a vehicle. It is purely on loan and they can remove the right to registration if a problem arises.

The “8 points” system is how they determine whether a car should retain its original registration. First they assign each major part of the car a set point score like this.

• chassis or body shell (body and chassis as one unit - monocoque ie direct replacement from the manufacturer) (original or new) = 5 points
• suspension = 2 points
• axles = 2 points
• transmission = 2 points
• steering assembly = 2 points
• engine = 1 point

To retain it’s original registration, the vehicle must score 8 or more points from this list. However this must always include the 5 points for the original UNMODIFIED monocoque shell/chassis. This doesn’t sound too bad, but say for a Mk2 Golf with a VR6 or 1.8T conversion, aftermarket suspension and a disk brake axle on the rear you’d have 7 points. The problem with this system is that if/when you take your car to be DVLA inspected it is down to the tester’s discretion on whether he allocates the points or not. The DVLA actually define each part as "the original part that the vehicle left the factory with". Obviously this is impossible to implement, as all the parts listed have at least a fair chance of being replaced throughout the life of a vehicle, not for modification but for warranty claims and servicing. For instance it's fair to say that if you go to a test with performance suspension parts fitted rather than OEM standard replacements you will lose those points.

What constitutes an Unmodified Monocoque?

Firstly it’s probably best to explain what a monocoque shell constitutes. From the DVLA definition:

“What constitutes a monocoque is that of how an OEM manufacturer would view it. The chassis or `cage` assembly and all components that form it, less any cosmetic panels or infills that make no structural consideration to the monocoque or its component parts.”


What this means

Your car WON’T need an IVA if you:

• Roll/Flare the wheel arches
• Fit different cosmetic panels (i.e. front end conversion, US/JDM body panels)
• Fit a roll cage (aslong as the existing shell isn’t cut to fit it – holes through bulkhead to fit bracing bars to strut tops a no-no for instance)
• Fit/remove a sunroof aslong as you don’t chop any strengthening members.
• Convert a car to a van – as you are adding to the existing structure.

Your car WILL need an IVA if you:
•C notch the chassis legs for driveshaft clearance
•Raise the strut tops
•Modify the floor or bulkhead
•Chop the roof off/convert to a pickup
•Cut the outer arch lip for tyre clearance/to fit a wide arch kit, as this is classed as a structural area
•Modify any part of the monocoque

From reading the DVLA rules as long as you don’t add to the width or length of the vehicle it is fine to add strength to the monocoque. Therefore if you weld plate over the existing chassis legs and fill the holes in the bulkhead to smooth an engine bay you should be fine. However if you cut the bulkhead out and weld in a complete flat sheet section, or chop the chassis legs out and refabricate in box section you will be liable to IVA the vehicle.

How is this enforced?

These seem to be the main ways that people are caught in contravention of the rules:
• Changing body type on V5 – If you send off the V5 with the body type changed it will automatically flag up the car for an inspection.
• VOSA/Police Spot Check – If you are pulled into a VOSA/Police checkpoint they can pass information onto the DVLA if the vehicle is not what it says on the log book.
• Flagging up modified vehicles for inspection at shows and from magazine articles - keep your registration plates/chassis number (if visible to outside i.e. in windscreen) hidden if possible to make it more difficult.

There is a rumour flying around that they are going to give the MOT tester a “modified vehicle” button which he has to check if a modified vehicle goes for an MOT. If this is checked it will flag the vehicle up for inspection. However there is no evidence to say this is in the pipeline.

What happens if my car is flagged for inspection?

If your car is flagged for inspection you will be summoned to the nearest DVLA office. A trained inspector will then go over the car allocating points based on the above values. If the car passes the inspection the vehicle will retain its registration certificate. If the car doesn’t pass the inspection it’s registration certificate will be revoked, meaning that the car cannot be used on the road.

To re-register the vehicle it must pass through an IVA test.

The IVA test

The IVA test is a stringent inspection to register amateur built/radically altered vehicles. It was implemented as the old SVA test had no class for inspecting radically altered vehicles.

The test is too stringent to go into in a forum post. There is a PDF of the manual here

http://mcelroymotors...0may 2009.pdf

Most cars post mid 70s are type approved, and therefore in standard form should easily pass an IVA test. However in modified form it may be more difficult. There is definitely no way that a car running poke, stretched tyres or scrub line interference will pass. The best thing would be to print a copy of the manual off, buy a radius tool off ebay and go through each pointer making sure it will pass. It's laborious, but on the plus side it will give you an insight into how much though goes into designing a car to pass crash safety tests.

Costs

The costs of an IVA test are fairly high, around £450 (no vat), then £99 (no vat) for a re-test if you fail.

Chances of getting caught

Put simply, there is no way of knowing. There are thousands of cars that are still using their original registration number when they should be having an IVA test. You could drive around for 10 years and never get a whiff of an inspection, but on the other hand you could apply to swap onto a private plate, or an engine swap, and get flagged for inspection. It really is pot luck, but as time goes on there is a good chance they’ll find new ways to catch people out.

There is a current proposal that the DVLA local offices will be closed and their powers given to the Police/VOSA. Apart from the fact that it will mean the people doing the inspections will be more clued up on modified vehicles, I feel it could also give more ammunition to the police to clamp down on modified cars that whilst not necessarily illegal in basic terms (MOT, tax, insurance present) fall foul of the regulations.
 

toby1

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 13, 2007
Messages
5,137
Reaction score
600
Location
West Berkshire
Your Mercedes
1998 CL420 C140; 1997 SL500 R129
We only needed the 1st section on this thread! And it's been covered before pretty comprehensively on the forum in general.
 

Robbostanhill

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 22, 2011
Messages
602
Reaction score
1
Location
Dartford, Kent, UK
Your Mercedes
E270 Estate 2003 and *Her* C220 W203
I feel that the Uk renouncing the EU on various legalities and cherry picking the laws is pathetic. If a car is blatantly showing out of alignment headlights of obviously crappy colours then nick it. Otherwise a proviso to have them correctly adjusted and a producer to show it's been done properly should suffice.
 

Robbostanhill

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 22, 2011
Messages
602
Reaction score
1
Location
Dartford, Kent, UK
Your Mercedes
E270 Estate 2003 and *Her* C220 W203
What ????

My motto is stick with the lights the car was designed with,if you want to upgrade,do it properly using the recommended parts for the job.

There are 1000,s of these not road legal bulbs for sale on E Bay,perhaps the clampdowns should start with the distributers and sellers of the not road legal bulbs.

The get out clause is the same old chesnut,these are designed for shows and off road only, just like the number plates that are everywhere on the road,another clampdown coming.

People only have thereselves to blame if they buy such tat.

Have you missed the point here?
It's not the legality of the bulbs themselves is it, nor is it the fact that people actually *want* to see further/better/clearer, it's about the effects of dazzle, improperly adjusted lights and ineffective beam spread causing issues for other road users.

My SLK230 headlights when I purchased the car were suffering very badly from condensation/damp *inside* the glass. ( A known problem)
I stripped, cleaned, and resealed them properly while at the same time fitting HID light bulb kit purchased from eBay from a Chinese supplier.
It is lower wattage, lower consumption in amps and the beam spread, as verified by my MOT station 100 yards away is as the original.
How does that make any of this kit "Tat" ?

The Uk following the EU and other countries like sheep is the problem.
"Uniformity" across the EU isn't necessary nor productive and indeed has previously been problematic.
See http://www.vwwatercooled.org.au/for...trofit-hid-lights-your-non-hid-car-56449.html for the Australian take on the issue

If headlights are out of alignment due to HIDs, extra bright Halogens, or other associated issues such as colour range or "Following the cars steering wheels" (Ex Citroen etc) the police or the all encompassing VOSA busybodies should issue a rectification notice and check it's been done or the MOT station fail it, or readjust as many do to allow it to pass. But hey... Hild on... Wouldn't that mean extra burden on them actually *doing* the re-checks therefore cost the government money?

Aftermarket kits such as the one I have fitted if used correctly and properly adjusted work well, give a longer viewing capacity ahead and are clearer light output.

But if you only travel around in an Austin 7 with **** poor lights and run someone over because of poor ageing design would it make you exempt from prosecution because you hadn't improved the issue of poor lighting?
I think not !
 
Last edited:

Mounis

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 25, 2005
Messages
233
Reaction score
1
Age
46
Location
Oxford
Your Mercedes
E220CDI W211 Avant
I've got xenons on my E270. when you switch them on at night you can see a warm blue glow that gradually becomes brighter but the lights dont adjust up or down (like they do on on other cars in the family, where you can see a distinct flicker as the beam travels up and the rests at the correct level.

Thus I'm thinking that the xenons are connected to the suspension for leveling purposes. Having said that my rear shocks are on their way out - so does that mean my lights ara aimed too high and if so, are they illegal?
 

MotardMan

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2003
Messages
895
Reaction score
13
Location
Berkshire, UK
Your Mercedes
1995 E320T, S124, W124, Sportline
Shocks or dampers do not support the car in any way, the springs do.

Worn dampers will affect the ride and the control of the body, but not the ride height.

HTH.
 

jefrs

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 4, 2010
Messages
407
Reaction score
0
Location
Berkshire
Your Mercedes
S210 98 E320 Estate Av petrol full load
I am wondering how folks seem to fit these "HID Xenon" lamps in place of regular Halogen, and can easily swap back to Halogen, apparently without fitting the 25,000 Volt "Danger Of Death" firing pack for the pukka HID Xenon bulbs? Am I missing something?

Btw the ride height on an MB estate is governed by the self levelling rear suspension and the load, not just the springs, they compress. If you load the back down, it will want to ride lower to the ground, so the rear raises on the pump until level. Fully loaded with bodies, the front suspension will compress too. I think this means the Xenon system then senses (OSF wishbone) that the front suspension has been compressed and so raises the beams to illuminate the same distance ahead. It does not seem to react very quickly to movements of the wishbone. or the beams would be bouncing up and down like a fiddler's elbow over every bump in the road, nor does the self-levelling rear suspension. So yes, you need both self-levelling Xenon and self-levelling suspension.
 

television

Always remembered RIP
Joined
Mar 14, 2005
Messages
164,073
Reaction score
367
Age
89
Location
Daventry
Your Mercedes
2002 SL500, 216 CL500, all fully loaded
The market for the bulbs is very misleading, some advertise some 12v lamps as xenon, and they are not, the only true xenon's require the high voltage units to be fitted.
 

Miffy

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2008
Messages
7,356
Reaction score
4
Location
Bromley, London
Your Mercedes
CLK 320 CAB Elegance C208
That confusion comes from the fact they use the inert gas Xenon to keep the filament burning bright without burning out. So both lamps have Xenon gas inside the glass, but one uses a heated tungsten filament, the other uses high voltage to strike an arc
 

survey

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2009
Messages
769
Reaction score
23
Location
Suffolk
Your Mercedes
2012 C207 E250cdi Sport Coupe
My 2012 car has Xenons. The low beam doesn't dip to the left as in the past - is this correct? Also when switching to European side of road the beam just seems to have the peaks taken off rather again than a dip to the right.
 

M80

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2006
Messages
5,948
Reaction score
2,754
Location
Derbyshire
Your Mercedes
2014 639 Viano- 651, 5sp Auto. 2009 S211- 646, 5sp Auto.
That confusion comes from the fact they use the inert gas Xenon to keep the filament burning bright without burning out. So both lamps have Xenon gas inside the glass, but one uses a heated tungsten filament, the other uses high voltage to strike an arc

HID is a better description (abbreviation) and less letters to type.
As said the 12 volt xenon con jobs aren't discharge lamps just filament lamps.
Then there are the pretty blue coated lamps. Unless it's HID it's boy racer stuff and probably lasts a few hours before popping.
 

television

Always remembered RIP
Joined
Mar 14, 2005
Messages
164,073
Reaction score
367
Age
89
Location
Daventry
Your Mercedes
2002 SL500, 216 CL500, all fully loaded
My 2012 car has Xenons. The low beam doesn't dip to the left as in the past - is this correct? Also when switching to European side of road the beam just seems to have the peaks taken off rather again than a dip to the right.

Yes just covers that flip down to cut off the high part of the beam, the low beam is angled slightly to the left, not as much as they used to
 

survey

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2009
Messages
769
Reaction score
23
Location
Suffolk
Your Mercedes
2012 C207 E250cdi Sport Coupe
Yes just covers that flip down to cut off the high part of the beam, the low beam is angled slightly to the left, not as much as they used to

Thanks. Can always rely on you for an answer!
 


Chris Knott Insurance, see oursticky posts here!
www.ckinsurance.co.uk
Top Bottom