W169 160CDI five speed gearbox reliability, I need to know before buying one!

MGB281

New Registration
Joined
Jul 30, 2024
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Your Mercedes
W169 160CDI
Not new to Mercedes (we are on our second C class auto) but I am looking for a cheap but practical small car that is just for running around, taking garden rubbish to the tip etc. We are constrained on space on the driveway and we will need a towbar for a small trailer for the garden clippings etc. The W169 fits the bill nicely in terms of size both internal and external and you can tow a trailer unlike most small cars where a towbar is solely for a bike carrier.
I have seen a 160CDI locally that is in excellent condition but I was surprised to see it had a five speed gearbox rather than the six speed fitted to a 180CDI that I also looked at. To be honest the six speeds seem unnecessary in a compact car with a two litre diesel, my old Skoda Fabia performed perfectly with just five. Is the five speed just to save a little money or is it not strong enough for the higher powered cars. The gear first gear ratios are similar but the six speed gearbox does give slightly higher gearing in sixth but that is not a priority for us. Any guidance would be appreciated.
 
Top Bottom